Ad blocker interference detected!
Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers
Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.
Was Charlus Potter James Potter's Father?Read more >
Lucius Malfoy should have been arrested for threatening the school governors. There was plenty of overt evidence for that!
Why didn't he get arrested based on Harry, Dobbys potential testmonies that he was behind the opening of the chamber of Secrets?? The first acusation could also be used as evidenceRead more >
Does Miss Coll, Dumbledore or Kreacher ever say where it is?Read more >
Dumbledore says before he and Harry set off to the cave, that they are setting off to find and destroy one of Voldemort’s Horcruxes, yet when they get to the cave, they don’t seem to think about, or know how they are going to destroy the horcrux that they thought they were going to recover. When Dumbledore is about to drink the potion, he doesn’t know what the effects on him are going to be; he could be paralysed, forced to forget why he was there. He tells Harry to force the potion down him but he gives no instructions on what to do afterwards when the Horcrux is now accessible and Dumbledore is affected in whatever way by the potion. You would have expected him to perhaps tell him to destroy it (presumably with Godric Gryffindor's swo…Read more >
Why didn't Regulus at least find out how to destroy horcruxes before he set out to the cave knowing he had to die? It doesn't make sense that he would hunt a horcrux down but not try and find out how to destroy them.
Why also didn't he just decide to live long enough to see the locket be destroyed? He could have lived longer had he either; got Kreacher to dissaparate him (using house elf magic) after he drank the water, learned how fight inferi [with fire as Dumbledore explained] and then with Kreacher supporting him, go back by boat to the entrance and then get dissaperated back to Grimmauld Place once outside.
If he believed there was only one horcrux, why couldn't he have drank the potion, see the horcrux be destroyed and then believing …Read more >