True, but we don't know for sure. We shouldn't assume they are the same person, so they should be treated as different characters until we know for sure. Jayden Matthews 21:06, 23 July 2009 (UTC)
- I think this woman was most likely Alecto. Her description in DH1 ("A broad, hunched woman with pointed teeth cackled") matches Alecto's: "sloping-shouldered" (DH29), "hunched" (DH30), and with a tendency to titter (HBP27), giggle (HBP27), and cackle (DH29). "Hunched" and "cackle" are rather specific words. If JKR had instead written "the greasy-haired, hook-nosed man gave a sneer," I wouldn't interpret it as referring someone other than Snape. In addition, Alecto and Bellatrix are the only female Death Eaters we know, and it would seem kind of superfluous to introduce a third only in passing. Still, since the hunched woman in DH1 isn't specifically identified as Alecto, I'm fine with keeping this article. ★ Starstuff (Owl me!) 15:20, 24 July 2009 (UTC)
I do not agree with Starstuff. And actually Starstuff is wrong at one point, we know five female Death Eaters. I think she is Alecto Carrow. Here is my reason:
Five female Death Eaters is already known:
This means that this Death Eater is Alecto.--Danniesen 07:49, October 26, 2011 (Denmark)
Next to Allecto Carrow, the dark and the white haired female Death Eaters there is also a fourth female Death Eater present at the meeting in the Movie Deathly Hallows Part 1.I'm don't think she is the descriped character but who knows.