Wikia

Harry Potter Wiki

Talk:Underground Chambers

11,851pages on
this wiki

Back to page

I would just do this myself, but my wiki experience is somewhat limited.

I'm currently re-reading the first book, and I noticed (as I noticed the first time I read it) that the potion riddle cannot be solved using only the information given in the book. This is because only the first, second, and fourth clues are useful to the reader. The third clue deals with the sizes of the different bottles (specifically the smallest and largest). However, the reader is not told the sizes of the seven individual bottles, which would of course be immediately apparent to the characters involved.

Personally, I felt somewhat cheated. As I began reading the riddle, I was eager to solve it myself before turning the page and seeing the characters solve it. I did the best I could with just clues one, two, and four, but it's unsolvable without all the clues. One could make an educated guess at the risk of one's life.

From what I gather on this article, there were varying versions of the riddle in each of the video games, and according to the article on the Stone itself, the DVD has an interactive version which is faithful to the book, in which I assume one can see the varying sizes.

Anyhow, to make a long story short, I think this article should briefly mention that the riddle is unsolvable using only the information given in the book, and perhaps that the full version can be seen and solved on the DVD. This should either go under the "Sixth Obstacle" heading or the "Behind the scenes" heading.

Thank you.

--Turambar007 08:38, 10 August 2009 (UTC)

This information would belong under "Behind the scenes." All other sections are written from an in-universe perspective, and, from the perspective of the characters, Snape's riddle was be solvable, as they could see the sizes of all the bottles. :) Starstuff (Owl me!) 20:43, 16 August 2009 (UTC)


For those that want to solve the puzzle the way Hermione had to do it: the puzzle is uniquely solvable only if you assume either potions 2 and 3 from the left to be the dwarf and giant bottles, or potions 3 and 6. Other bottle sizes either conflict with the hints and the solution as provided by the main article, or allow for multiple solutions (requiring the solver to guess). Unfortunately, with these assumptions the puzzle becomes rather easy, not exactly something worth of Severus Snape. 145.120.13.65 17:28, April 21, 2010 (UTC)


Table

I'd like to do this myself but I don't know how. The table in the "Behind the Scenes" section is missing the PS2 game stats. Can someone change that because I don't know how to do that. Secret agent clank 08:43, October 31, 2010 (UTC)

Info box

Shouldn't this have a location info box, as it was a series of chambers and not one specific object? --BachLynnGryffindorcrest(Accio!) 01:39, January 8, 2011 (UTC)

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki