Harry Potter Wiki
Register
Harry Potter Wiki
(→‎Name: new section)
 
Line 5: Line 5:
   
 
I have marked the article with a <nowiki>{{Conjecture}}</nowiki> tag given that the article was first created as "Remonstrate Spell" then immediately changed to "Harvesting Spell" before categories were even added; if this is inaccurate (the name is correct as is: "Harvesting Spell") please remove the tag, and if the name needs to be changed then "spell" in the name should perhaps be un-capitalised, or maybe a more specific name should be thought up ("spell-harvesting charm", perhaps?) because "Harvesting Spell" sounded IMO like a [[Crop-related charms|crop-related charm]], not a defensive charm. --[[User:Hunnie Bunn|Hunnie Bunn]] ([[User talk:Hunnie Bunn|talk]]) 22:13, May 10, 2014 (UTC)
 
I have marked the article with a <nowiki>{{Conjecture}}</nowiki> tag given that the article was first created as "Remonstrate Spell" then immediately changed to "Harvesting Spell" before categories were even added; if this is inaccurate (the name is correct as is: "Harvesting Spell") please remove the tag, and if the name needs to be changed then "spell" in the name should perhaps be un-capitalised, or maybe a more specific name should be thought up ("spell-harvesting charm", perhaps?) because "Harvesting Spell" sounded IMO like a [[Crop-related charms|crop-related charm]], not a defensive charm. --[[User:Hunnie Bunn|Hunnie Bunn]] ([[User talk:Hunnie Bunn|talk]]) 22:13, May 10, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
: I changed the name because it didn't really make sense. Magic doesnt 'Remonstrate'; also the spell seems to harvest surrounding spells to be used. Uncapitilising the 'S' as the spell isn't named. [[user:HeWhoHasNoName]]! 00:26, May 11, 2014 (UTC)

Revision as of 00:26, 11 May 2014

Name

GSnitch This discussion is listed as an active talk page.
Please remove this template when the question has been answered.

I was (and still am) uncertain of the veracity of this spell, though as there are both an image and a source backing up the claims made by the creator of the article, I suppose this is, to use the common phrase, "legit".

I have marked the article with a {{Conjecture}} tag given that the article was first created as "Remonstrate Spell" then immediately changed to "Harvesting Spell" before categories were even added; if this is inaccurate (the name is correct as is: "Harvesting Spell") please remove the tag, and if the name needs to be changed then "spell" in the name should perhaps be un-capitalised, or maybe a more specific name should be thought up ("spell-harvesting charm", perhaps?) because "Harvesting Spell" sounded IMO like a crop-related charm, not a defensive charm. --Hunnie Bunn (talk) 22:13, May 10, 2014 (UTC)

I changed the name because it didn't really make sense. Magic doesnt 'Remonstrate'; also the spell seems to harvest surrounding spells to be used. Uncapitilising the 'S' as the spell isn't named. user:HeWhoHasNoName! 00:26, May 11, 2014 (UTC)