Wikia

Harry Potter Wiki

Talk:Sally Smith

12,054pages on
this wiki

Back to page

I just found that the two missing Gryffindor are Sophie Roper and Sally Smith.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrJiAG8GmnQ#t=516

The picture is very confused, but looking very very very carefully you can note who are the Gryffindors, because JKR "circled the written". —The preceding unsigned comment was added by GianG (talkcontribs).

So sorry, but further proof is required. The list of names is barely visible on that shot, let alone the house attributions. --  Seth Cooper  owl post! 00:39, December 20, 2014 (UTC)
I know it is difficult to read, however looking very carefully at the letters that indicate the houses, you can notice the second letter, the fourth, the sixth, the seventh, the ninth, the eleventh and the thirteenth (FROM BELOW) are circled. After I discovered the circled letters, I looked for the names in the list and they were Ronald Weasley, Gary Thomas, Sally Smith, Sidebottom Neville, Sophie Roper, Hermione Puckle and Harry Potter. I didn't find the circle around Mati/Madhari Patel's and Neville Puff's letters, but the other circles can be noted, so this should be a sufficient proof.
PS: I actually thought the missing Gryffindors were Sally-Anne Perks and Sophie Roper. I was a bit emblittered when I discovered the truth.
GianG (talk) 13:08, December 20, 2014 (UTC)
Again, the video hasn't got nearly enough resolution to show anything of substance in that page. All I can see are blobs of ink, and I can't really distinguish anything between them -- they could easily be any of the four letters, or be or not circled. We need a higher-resolution clip, since this reasoning is sketchy and entirely questionable (you pointed it out yourself, what with the Neville and the Patil situation). It's a simple case of erring on the side of caution instead of outright saying something we are not sure of. --  Seth Cooper  owl post! 14:53, December 20, 2014 (UTC)

An error: not all five female Slytherins are known, there is one unknown Slytherin female. She could be in Slytherin.

An error: not all five female Slytherins are known, there is one unknown Slytherin female. She could be in Slytherin.

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki