Talk: Room of Requirement

Revision as of 09:31, 6 January 2012

Room of Hidden Things

Should we have a seperate article for this? I think it deserves one, being the location of several major events, but I wanted to check what other users thought. QuidditchLover ^{(My talk)(contribs)} 03:23, November 18, 2009 (UTC)

I don't think a separate article is necessary, but the "History of Use" section could probably by retitled, expanded, and divided into each of the room's known forms:

Room of Hidden Things
Dumbledore's Army room (1995-1996 school year)
Dumbledore's Army room (1997-1998 school year)
Chamberpot room (mentioned by Dumbledore in GoF)
House-elf sobriety room (used by Dobby for Winky)
Cleaning supplies closet (Dobby mentions Filch finding it like this once)
Broom cupboard (Fred and George mention hiding from Filch in here)

The "Items Hidden Inside" section could also be relocated under the Room of Hidden Things, with a similar section added for each version of the D.A. room at least. - Nick O'Demus 09:36, November 18, 2009 (UTC)

That sounds okay... although it sounds like a massive re-write.. Hmm.. Maybe I'll try it out. QuidditchLover

^{(My talk)(contribs)} 00:15, November 19, 2009 (UTC)

Destruction

Was it destroyed by the Fiendfyre? What happened to the room, did the room never work anymore, or was everything in it destroyed, or was it on fire if you entered, or did the fire burn out, or did it get stinguished, or did everything go back to normal once everyone got out? 75.27.36.231 16:52, September 14, 2010 (UTC)

Summoning Charm

I was under the impression that the diadem wouldn't come because it was horcrux, not specifically because it was in the room of hidden things. --BachLynn ^(Accio!) 00:22, October 4, 2010 (UTC)

HP3 movie appearing?

I can't give a screenshot, but when Harry Potter is searching for Peter Pettigrew in the castle, you can briefly see room down their names. Could this being this room? It's also not far from the portraits. --Station7 22:30, January 5, 2012 (UTC)

Doesn't seem likely - the books indicate that the Room doesn't show up on the map. Is there a particular reason you think it would be this room? ProfessorTofty 22:49, January 5, 2012 (UTC)

First of all, I see "Room" briefly in the movie. There's nothing down there. It's possible, but yes it's unlikely that that's room. It's just a theory, but I saw it, and I did want to share it with everyone here. --Station7 09:31, January 6, 2012 (UTC)

@@ Line 2: / Line 2: @@
 Should we have a seperate article for this? I think it deserves one, being the location of several major events, but I wanted to check what other users thought. [[User:Quidditch Lover|<font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color=gold>Q</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">u</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="gold">i</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">d</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="gold">d</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">i</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="gold">t</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">c</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="gold">h</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">L</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="gold">o</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">v</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="gold">e</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">r</font color>]][[File:Snitch 2.jpg|60px]]<sup>[[User talk:Quidditch Lover|<font face="Script MT Bold" size=3  color="gold">(My <font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color=green>talk)</font>]]</font>[[Special:Contributions/Quidditch Lover|<font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color=gold>(cont</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color=green>ribs)</font color></sup>]] 03:23, November 18, 2009 (UTC)
-:I don't think a separate article is necessary, but the "History of Use" section could probably by retitled and divided into the room's known forms:
+:I don't think a separate article is necessary, but the "History of Use" section could probably by retitled, expanded, and divided into each of the room's known forms:
 :*Room of Hidden Things
 :*Dumbledore's Army room (1995-1996 school year)
@@ Line 9: / Line 9: @@
 :*House-elf sobriety room (used by Dobby for Winky)
 :*Cleaning supplies closet (Dobby mentions Filch finding it like this once)
-:*Broom cupboard (Fred and Geaorge mention hiding from Filch in here)
+:*Broom cupboard (Fred and George mention hiding from Filch in here)
-:[[User:Nick O'Demus|<font face="Monotype Corsiva" size="4" color="FF8000">Nick O'Demus</font>]] 09:36, November 18, 2009 (UTC)
+:The "Items Hidden Inside" section could also be relocated under the Room of Hidden Things, with a similar section added for each version of the D.A. room at least. - [[User:Nick O'Demus|<font face="Monotype Corsiva" size="4" color="FF8000">Nick O'Demus</font>]] 09:36, November 18, 2009 (UTC)
+::That sounds okay... although it sounds like a massive re-write.. Hmm.. Maybe I'll try it out. [[User:Quidditch Lover|<font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color=gold>Q</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">u</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="gold">i</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">d</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="gold">d</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">i</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="gold">t</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">c</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="gold">h</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">L</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="gold">o</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">v</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="gold">e</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color="green">r</font color>]][[File:Snitch 2.jpg|60px]]<sup>[[User talk:Quidditch Lover|<font face="Script MT Bold" size=3  color="gold">(My <font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color=green>talk)</font>]]</font>[[Special:Contributions/Quidditch Lover|<font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color=gold>(cont</font color><font face="Script MT Bold" size=3 color=green>ribs)</font color></sup>]] 00:15, November 19, 2009 (UTC)
+== Destruction ==
+Was it destroyed by the Fiendfyre? What happened to the room, did the room never work anymore, or was everything in it destroyed, or was it on fire if you entered, or did the fire burn out, or did it get stinguished, or did everything go back to normal once everyone got out? [[Special:Contributions/75.27.36.231|75.27.36.231]] 16:52, September 14, 2010 (UTC)
+== Summoning Charm ==
+I was under the impression that the diadem wouldn't come because it was horcrux, not specifically because it was in the room of hidden things. --[[User:BachLynn23|<font face="Ariel" size="4" color="Purple" >BachLynn</font>]][[File:Gryffindorcrest.jpg|33px]]<sup>([[User talk:BachLynn23|<font face="Monotype Corsiva" size="2" color="Purple">Accio!</font>]])</sup> 00:22, October 4, 2010 (UTC)
+==HP3 movie appearing?==
+I can't give a screenshot, but when [[Harry Potter]] is searching for [[Peter Pettigrew]] in the castle, you can briefly see room down their names. Could this being this room? It's also not far from the portraits. --[[User:Station7|Station7]] 22:30, January 5, 2012 (UTC)
+:Doesn't seem likely - the books indicate that the Room doesn't show up on the map. Is there a particular reason you think it would be this room? [[User:ProfessorTofty|ProfessorTofty]] 22:49, January 5, 2012 (UTC)
+::First of all, I see "Room" briefly in the movie. There's nothing down there. It's possible, but yes it's unlikely that that's room. It's just a theory, but I saw it, and I did want to share it with everyone here. --[[User:Station7|Station7]] 09:31, January 6, 2012 (UTC)