Isn't is possible that this isn't actually Mary I? We know that the prop makers for the films have used historic portraits as models for Hogwarts paintings (i.e, the portrait of Basil Fronsac is based on Henry James, the portrait of Elizabeth Burke is based on Bess of Hardwick, the portrait of George von Rheticus is based on King James I, etc.). Couldn't the case be the same here? -- Parodist 13:29, August 2, 2011 (UTC)