No edit summary Tag: rte-wysiwyg |
|||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
::I'm agree with that. Timeline : "Moment where there's 2 skrewts" - Later "Third task" with Diggory saying that he saw SkrewtS - Later "Moment where there's 1 skrewt". I put in the french wiki that the maze contained 1 or 2, here it's categoric in your article, it's just what I want to say. Maybe 1, maybe 2, maybe one skrewt killed by Diggory, maybe one skrewt killed by another in the maze, there's a lot of suppositions possible but we should consider the plural in the citation. --[[User:Famini71|Famini71]] 16:34, September 11, 2009 (UTC) |
::I'm agree with that. Timeline : "Moment where there's 2 skrewts" - Later "Third task" with Diggory saying that he saw SkrewtS - Later "Moment where there's 1 skrewt". I put in the french wiki that the maze contained 1 or 2, here it's categoric in your article, it's just what I want to say. Maybe 1, maybe 2, maybe one skrewt killed by Diggory, maybe one skrewt killed by another in the maze, there's a lot of suppositions possible but we should consider the plural in the citation. --[[User:Famini71|Famini71]] 16:34, September 11, 2009 (UTC) |
||
| + | |||
| + | Hermonie seamed out of charicter by thinking they should be killed. |
||
| + | |||
| + | she did not even like the spider being killed. |
||
| + | |||
| + | this seams out of charicter for her |
||
Revision as of 17:35, 22 April 2015
Number of skrewts in the maze
Hi, Are you sure for the third task ? I think there's probably 2 skrewts in the maze, not only one. In HP4 chapter 26, it's mentionned that there's 2 skrewts left. In HP4 chapter 31, Cedric Diggory says to Harry "Hagrid’s Blast-Ended Skrewts!” after he has met this creature. There's a plural. Harry only see one, mais no sure that there is only one, no ? (sorry for my bad english) French --Famini71 09:42, September 11, 2009 (UTC)
- Maybe, although Hagrid later jokingly asks Harry, Ron, and Hermione if they want to visit the last Skrewt with him. - Nick O'Demus 16:20, September 11, 2009 (UTC)
- I'm agree with that. Timeline : "Moment where there's 2 skrewts" - Later "Third task" with Diggory saying that he saw SkrewtS - Later "Moment where there's 1 skrewt". I put in the french wiki that the maze contained 1 or 2, here it's categoric in your article, it's just what I want to say. Maybe 1, maybe 2, maybe one skrewt killed by Diggory, maybe one skrewt killed by another in the maze, there's a lot of suppositions possible but we should consider the plural in the citation. --Famini71 16:34, September 11, 2009 (UTC)
Hermonie seamed out of charicter by thinking they should be killed.
she did not even like the spider being killed.
this seams out of charicter for her