Talk:Alecto Carrow

In the Harry Potter and The Goblet Of Fire film, when Lord Voldemort regain his body and some Death Eaters appear... There can be seen there a woman Death Eater with the same physical characteristics as described here, I think she's Alecto Carrow.

There are some scenes that you can clearly see her face in almost a close up, someone should get a screencap and post it. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 189.153.171.8 (talk • contribs).

Firstly, please sign your edit with four ~ so we know who is talking! Secondly, unless the film credits or offical source state that the woman is Alecto Carrow, then we cannot make the assumption that she is. Take the Order of the Phoenix film for example - several Death Eaters, none mentioned by name in the film or the credits. We can just say that one of them was, for example, Jugson, just because he was there in the book. - Cavalier One 07:12, 19 September 2007 (UTC)

You are right Cavalier One... i'm sorry. We can't be sure if she's her... But anyway, since there are not so many woman Death Eaters, the most probable is that she is Alecto Carrow, but we can't assure that. At least we can make a visual idea about how Alecto Carrow is (or will be in the film), not only with words ; )... regards

i'll sign this time... : )

CeDlaGé 22:21, 20 September 2007 (UTC)

I do wish that the film makers would accurately identify characters in the films and match them to their book counterparts, but we can't have everything! Of course, if they decide to cast someone as Alecto Carrow in the last movie, then the chances are that it will not be the same actress as Goblet of Fire. Incidently, why not register your user name here instead of editting under an IP address? - Cavalier One 07:37, 21 September 2007 (UTC)

In the second Trailer of the six movie she is seen with Snape and Malfoy and her brother she looks nothing like the girl from GOF I always considerd that girl to be Narcrissca or one of the death eaters wives.