(non-magical) |
m (adding the unsigned template for attribution on the original question to RavenclawGirl) |
||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
| − | I would like to know why 'logic' and 'genius' are not on Snape's Magical ability's section. They are listed in Hermonies profile, but not Snape's, why? |
+ | I would like to know why 'logic' and 'genius' are not on Snape's Magical ability's section. They are listed in Hermonies profile, but not Snape's, why? {{unsigned|RavenclawGirl}} |
:It's not my decision, but I'd say it doesn't belong under magical abilities on either. Those are abilities for non-magical folks as well. In fact, in one of the books, the point is made that few witches and wizards are good at logic (In the first book, when they are trying to get to the [[sorcerer's stone]] I think.) So, while both Snape and Hermione are of above average intelligence and able to solve logical puzzles, I wouldn't put it under magical abilities. -- [[User:CocoaZen|CocoaZen]] 19:36, February 6, 2011 (UTC) |
:It's not my decision, but I'd say it doesn't belong under magical abilities on either. Those are abilities for non-magical folks as well. In fact, in one of the books, the point is made that few witches and wizards are good at logic (In the first book, when they are trying to get to the [[sorcerer's stone]] I think.) So, while both Snape and Hermione are of above average intelligence and able to solve logical puzzles, I wouldn't put it under magical abilities. -- [[User:CocoaZen|CocoaZen]] 19:36, February 6, 2011 (UTC) |
||
Revision as of 19:38, 6 February 2011
I would like to know why 'logic' and 'genius' are not on Snape's Magical ability's section. They are listed in Hermonies profile, but not Snape's, why? —The preceding unsigned comment was added by RavenclawGirl (talk • contribs).
- It's not my decision, but I'd say it doesn't belong under magical abilities on either. Those are abilities for non-magical folks as well. In fact, in one of the books, the point is made that few witches and wizards are good at logic (In the first book, when they are trying to get to the sorcerer's stone I think.) So, while both Snape and Hermione are of above average intelligence and able to solve logical puzzles, I wouldn't put it under magical abilities. -- CocoaZen 19:36, February 6, 2011 (UTC)